
Team Champions
NYSPHSAA Long Island Champions
| 2016 | Boys Basketball | vs. East Rockaway |
| 2013 | Boys Basketball | vs. Friends Academy |
| 2011 | Girls Basketball | vs. Friends Academy |
| 2010 | Boys Basketball | vs. Friends Academy |
| 2010 | Girls Basketball | vs. East Rockaway |
| 2009 | Girls Soccer | vs. Friends Academy |
| 2009 | Girls Basketball | vs. Oyster Bay |
| 2008 | Girls Soccer | vs. Friends Academy |
| 2007 | Girls Soccer | vs. Friends Academy |
| 2007 | Girls Basketball | vs. Friends Academy |
| 1999 | Baseball |
Long Island Champions
| 1960 | Fencing | vs. Eastern Military Academy |
Individual Champions
| 1937 | Norman Aarseth | Wrestling |
| 1937 | Paul Bickford | Wrestling |
| 1937 | Arthur Elliot, Jr. | Wrestling |
| 1937 | Paul Landis | Wrestling |
| 1936 | Norman Aarseth | Wrestling |
| 1936 | Paul Bickford | Wrestling |
| 1936 | Arthur Elliot, Jr. | Wrestling |
| 1936 | Paul Landis | Wrestling |

