What better day than Independence Day to celebrate the amazing accomplishments of our high school and collegiate All-Americans? Here is a list of our nationally recognized athletes.
High School All-Americans
| Scott Dodd | 1976 | Wrestling |
| Andy Whitney | 1978 | Cross Country |
| Laura Whitney | 1977-1981 | Cross Country |
| Laura Whitney | 1980 | 2 Mile |
| Roger Wycoff | 1984 | 500 Freestyle |
| Anne Marie Wycoff | 1985 | Swimming |
| Will Smith | 1993 | 200 Freestyle Relay |
| Jean Crousillat | 1993-1994 | 200 Freestyle Relay |
| Jonathan Meltzer | 1993-1994 | 200 Freestyle Relay |
| Steven Meltzer | 1993-1994 | 200 Freestyle Relay |
| Casey O’Donnell | 1994 | 200 Freestyle Relay |
| Jake Kenney | 1996 | Lacrosse |
Collegiate All-Americans
| Alfred Van Ranst ’35 | 1937 | Cornell University | Football |
| Frank Visted ’57 | 1960 | Navy | Football |
| Robin Lingle ’60 | 1965 | University of Missouri | 1,000 & Mile |
| Glenn Ogden ’65 | 1967 | University of Missouri | Cross Country |
| Harold Spooner ’70 | 1974 | Houghton College | Basketball |
| Don Lockerbie ’75 | 1977 & 1979 | University of North Carolina | Track |
| Scott Dodd ’77 | 1981 | Taylor University | Wrestling |
| Ann Marie Wycoff ’85 | 1987-1988 (19x) | Army | Swimming |
| Jordan Nixon ’88 | 1991 | Augustana College | Football |
| Dan Shanks ’92 | 1997 | Coker College | Basketball |
| Matt Mattimore ’95 | 1998 | Georgetown University | Football |
| Dianne Grimm ’96 | 2000 | University of Mary Washington | Lacrosse |
| Liam Banks ’98 | 2000-2001 | Syracuse University | Lacrosse |
| Caitlin Banks ’00 | 2004 | University of Virginia | Lacrosse |
| Nick Miaritis ’01 | 2005 | Georgetown University | Lacrosse |
| Will Lingle ’02 | 2003 | Wheaton College | 800 Meters |
| Greg Titus ’03 | 2007-2008 | Salisbury University | Lacrosse |
| Amanda Shapiro ’04 | 2006-2007 | Wesleyan College | 100 & 200 Breaststroke |
| Kenny Ruddick ’09 | 2014 | Suffolk Community College | 4×400 Meter Relay |

